The Weblog Awards

Fourth Annual Weblog Awards: The 2004 Bloggies

Every January, intense campaigning and mudslinging rages among Web celebrities, Trekkies, and the citizens of Dallas. And they do it all for
the Bloggie™.

The Bloggies™ are publicly-chosen awards given to weblog writers and those related to weblogs. 90 awards were presented over 2001, 2002, and 2003, and 30 more will be given out this year.

I'm Nikolai Nolan, and these are the...

the rules

Hey, you. Read these. They're shorter than last year's.

In the 2004 Weblog Awards™, a "weblog" is a page with dated entries. The contest is open to any weblogs that existed for a period of time during the year 2003, so weblogs that were discontinued during 2003 are also eligible.

Only one nomination form and one finalist voting form may be submitted per person. E-mail addresses are required for this reason, and you must use your own address. If you resubmit a ballot, your old one will be erased.

For the nomination phase (not applicable now): URLs are required (where applicable). The maximum number of weblogs you may nominate for a category is three for most categories and four for Weblog of the Year. At least three different weblogs total must be nominated. You may nominate your own weblog, but the total nominations for your own weblog must be less than one third of your total (legitimate) nominations. There is no limit to the number of categories a weblog may be nominated for.

Nominees have to fit the category they are placed in. The system alerts me of suspicious ballots, and I also may exclude ballots when I suspect the voter isn't following the rules. This means no bots.

These rules may change at any time, but they probably won't.

the procedure

From January 1, 2004 until 10:00 PM Eastern Standard Time (GMT-5) on Monday, January 12, voters nominated their favorite weblogs.

That Tuesday, January 13, three panels of 50 voters received an e-mail. It listed the weblogs that have receieved the most nominations in ten categories. They had until 10:00 PM EST on Saturday, January 17 to privately submit their five favorites (six for Weblog of the Year) for each category. The five (or six for Weblog of the Year) receiving the most votes became finalists. I (Nikolai Nolan) only voted in the case of a tie for fifth place. This panel was on an opt-in policy.

On Monday, January 19, the finalists were announced and voting opened again to choose the winners.

Voting closed at 10:00 PM EST on Saturday, January 31. The winners were posted on Monday, March 15.

the ceremony

The Weblog Awards™ ceremony was held at the South by Southwest Interactive Festival for the second time in Austin, Texas, USA on Monday, March 15, 2004 at 12:30 PM. Webloggers including previous winners and prize donators presented the certificates and prizes to those present.

I performed "Win a Bloggie," a parody of Justin Timberlake's "Rock Your Body." An MP3 of the song is now available. I also showed a weblog-themed video parody of Van Halen's "Right Now." That will go online as a future Fairvue feature.

Those who weren't attending could join the excitement on IRC, in #BlogIRC on irc.turlyming.com:6667. Winners were announced live and a play-by-play of the ceremony was given.

After the ceremony, the results were posted on this page.

the prizes

Because of the large amount of categories, I won't personally give a cash award to every winner, but the Weblog of the Year owner(s) will receive 2,004 US cents (US$20.04).

Also, contributors can donate their own prizes to the category of their choice, and if the contributor has a site, it will be linked from this page. If the contributor is going to SXSW, he/she can also have the privilege of announcing/presenting the category sponsored at the ceremony.

To donate one, the contributor can bring it to SXSW, mail it to the winner, or send an online gift certificate or cash through PayPal with instructions of what it should be used for.

South by Southwest Interactive offers Bloggie finalists a special discount to attend the ceremony in March. The cost of Interactive registration for Bloggie finalists is $150.

Dmitry Chestnykh contributed the full commercial version of BlogJet for each winner.

John Allsopp of WestCiv contributed a copy of Style Master (for Mac OS X or Windows) for each winner.

Thanks also go out to Jim McCann for programming expertise and Dinah Sanders for the Bloggies.com domain name.

the categories

Most categories will remain as they've always been. But because of revision or removal, it's time to bid farewell to:

Best Merchandise of a Weblog
Best Weblog Webring
Best Webcam of a Weblog Site
Best Reviews or Weblog About Weblogs

In exchange, these spiffy new categories took their place:

Best British or Irish Weblog
Best African or Middle Eastern Weblog
Best Photography of a Weblog

The voting is now over, and here are the winners!

best meme

A replicating idea that spread about weblogs.

Prize: US$50 gift certificate to Amazon.com from Ben Werdmuller

 

best article or essay about weblogs

Prize: US$50 gift certificate to eBay or Amazon.com from Camilo Ramirez

 

best weblog directory or update monitor

Prize: TBA from James Paden of Bot a Blog

 

best web application for weblogs

Something that helps you publish, make comments, anything that has to do with developing a weblog.

Prize: US$20.04 from Chris MacDonald

"Blogumentary" cap from Chuck Olsen of Blogumentary

 

best australian or new zealand weblog

Prize: AUS$20 gift voucher to Coles Myer or Grace Bros from Ben Hosken

 

best asian weblog

Weblogs from Asia, not including the Middle East.

Prize: US20.04 (or equivalent) from YardBoy

 

best african or middle eastern weblog

Prize: TBA from Anthony

 

best european weblog

Weblogs from Europe, not including the United Kingdom and Ireland.

Prize: US20.04 (or equivalent) from SignorMori

 

best british or irish weblog

Weblogs from the United Kingdom and Ireland.

Prize: £20.04 from James Mitchell

 

best latin american weblog

Prize: US$20.04 (or equivalent) from JozJozJoz

 

best canadian weblog

Prize: The Sweet Potato Queens' Book of Love from the Ice Queen

 

best american weblog

Weblogs from the United States.

Prize: US$20.04 from The Blog Herald

 

best tagline of a weblog

Prize: US$40.08 from BlogAds

 

best photography of a weblog

Photoblogs and other weblogs that regularly feature photography.

Prize: US$10.02 from CheekySquirrel

A brand-new Holga with case and three rolls of black-and-white-film from Laura Sina

 

best non-weblog content of a weblog site

Prize: US$20.04 from David Grant

US$20.04 from Rita Beeman

 

best programming of a weblog site

Comments, sorting, customization, homemade stuff you like to see in a weblog.

Prize: US$20.04 from Rogers Cadenhead, author of Radio UserLand Kick Start

 

best weblog about music

Prize: US$50 gift certificate to the iTunes Music Store or Amazon.com from Jace Herring of BlogHosts

 

best weblog about politics

Prize: US$4 gift card to Best Buy from Anthony

US$40.08 from BlogAds

"Write Hard Die Free" pin or appropriate political pin from Patrick Race of Wm. Spear Design

"I Blog and I Vote" bumper sticker from Chuck Olsen of Blogumentary

 

best web development weblog

Weblogs completely about Web design and development.

Prize: US$20.04 from Adam of HeathNet Consulting, LLC

 

best computers or technology weblog

Weblogs about computers and/or technology, other than Web design.

Prize: US$20.04 from Christian of Coupon Craze

 

best topical weblog

Weblogs with a definite topic other than general/personal, music, politics, computers and technology, or weblogs.

Prize: US$40.08 from Douglas Kersten

US$20.04 from Rita Beeman

A pin or zipper pull related to the topic area of the winning weblog from Patrick Race of Wm. Spear Design

 

best glbt weblog

Webloggers in the gay/lesbian/bisexual/ transgendered community.

Prize: One item from the winner's Amazon.com wishlist, valued up to US$20.00, from Rannie Turingan and Jay Schneider

X and Y chromosome pins from Patrick Race of Wm. Spear Design

 

most humorous weblog

Prize: US$50 gift certificate to Amazon.com from Ben Werdmuller

 

best group weblog

Weblogs written by an exclusive group.

Prize: US$4 gift card to Best Buy from Anthony

A pin or zipper pull related to the topic area of the winning weblog from Patrick Race of Wm. Spear Design

 

best community weblog

Weblogs where everyone is invited to post.

Prize: US$20.04 from Christian of Coupon Craze

 

best-designed weblog

Prize: US$20.04 from Adam of HeathNet Consulting, LLC

 

best-kept-secret weblog

The best underrepresented weblogs.

Prize: US$20.04 from John Benyamine

US$20.04 from The Blog Herald

 

best new weblog

Weblogs that began during the year 2003.

Prize: US$11.00 from Jonathan Holley

US$50 gift certificate to the iTunes Music Store or Amazon.com from Jace Herring of BlogHosts

 

lifetime achievement

Webloggers who have been blogging at least since October 1, 2000. This award can only be won once, so Jeffrey Zeldman, Evan Williams, and Jason Kottke are not eligible.

Prize: Two registrations for the 2005 South by Southwest Interactive Festival from SXSW

 

weblog of the year

This is it: the category for the best weblog overall.

Prize: US$20.04 from Nikolai Nolan

A nifty award from Jish Mukerji

Two registrations for the 2005 South by Southwest Interactive Festival from SXSW

For each of the runners-up: US$10.00 from Christian of Coupon Craze